You Can Love Living Here Without Living on the Sand

If the beach isn't the reason you're moving, Conway is often the better home base. It's a river town and the Horry County seat, with bigger lots, a historic downtown and a quieter pace, roughly 20 to 30 minutes from the ocean. Carolina Forest sits in between, with newer subdivisions and quick access to Highway 501 and Highway 31. Myrtle Beach proper makes the most sense if you want restaurants, shopping and the airport close by.

I hear some version of this every week. "Greg, we don't really care about the beach. We just want a good place to live." That's a great place to start. It takes the most expensive part of the map off the table and lets you pick an area for how you actually spend your days. If that sounds like you, take a hard look at homes for sale in Conway, SC before you settle on anything closer to the ocean.

Conway Feels Like a Real Small Town

Conway has been here a long time, and it shows in the best way. Downtown Main Street has old brick storefronts, local restaurants and shops that have been around for years. The Conway Riverwalk follows the Waccamaw River under big live oaks. On a fall evening it's one of the nicest walks in Horry County, and you won't fight a single tourist for a parking spot.

Because Conway is the county seat, the courthouse and a lot of county offices are right there. Coastal Carolina University sits on the edge of town, so there's a steady flow of ballgames, concerts and campus events. Conway Medical Center is close by too, which matters more to people than they expect when they're picking a place to live.

Here's the thing most newcomers notice first. The lots are bigger. Plenty of Conway neighborhoods give you room for a shop, a garden, a boat in the driveway or just space between you and the neighbors. Some older homes sit on land you won't find closer to the coast. If you've been living on a postage-stamp lot up north, that alone can win you over.

Myrtle Beach or Conway? Choosing a Home Base If You're Not a Beach PersonGolf Without the Resort Feel

Not a beach person but a golf person? Conway has you covered. Wild Wing Plantation is a golf community off Highway 501 with established streets and a neighborhood feel that's more everyday living than vacation. According to CCMLS data, we've sold 48 homes in Wild Wing since 2006, so it's a neighborhood my team knows street by street.

What You Trade for the Quiet

The trade-off is the drive. Getting to the ocean from Conway takes roughly 20 to 30 minutes, depending on where you start and the time of year. That's nothing if you go once a month. It adds up if you end up working near the beach. Dining and shopping choices are smaller, too. Most Conway folks don't mind. They run to Myrtle Beach when they want something bigger and come home to the quiet.

Carolina Forest Is the Middle Ground Most People Pick

If Conway feels a little far out and the beach feels like too much, Carolina Forest is the in-between. It's a large area of newer subdivisions between Conway and Myrtle Beach, close to Highway 501 and Highway 31. That access is the selling point. You can reach Conway, the beach or the US-17 Bypass without much trouble.

Families like Carolina Forest for the schools and the newer homes. Retirees like it because many neighborhoods have pools, sidewalks and low-maintenance houses. My team has spent a lot of time out there. According to CCMLS data, The Farm in Carolina Forest is the neighborhood where we've sold the most homes since 2006, with 104 sales. The choices across Carolina Forest neighborhoods run from smaller starter homes to larger plans on quiet cul-de-sacs.

The catch is that most Carolina Forest homes come with an HOA. That brings rules on fences, sheds, parking and paint colors. Some people like the order. Others would rather do what they want with their own yard. Know which one you are before you sign.

Myrtle Beach Proper Still Wins for Convenience

You don't have to love the beach to love Myrtle Beach. Some non-beach people pick it for everything else. Market Common has walkable shops, restaurants and a movie theater, plus homes and townhomes within walking distance. Myrtle Beach International Airport is right next door, which is a big deal if your kids and grandkids fly in or you travel for work.

Living in town also puts you closer to Grand Strand Medical Center, more restaurant choices and more things to do on a random weeknight. The trade-off is more people, more traffic and, in most neighborhoods, smaller lots for the money.

Summer Traffic on Highway 501 Should Shape Your Choice

Here's what nobody tells you about choosing between Conway and Myrtle Beach. Highway 501 is the main road between them, and in summer it fills up with beach traffic. A Saturday in July is a different drive from a Tuesday in February. If you'll commute between Conway and the beach every day, drive that route during peak season before you commit.

The good news is that locals learn the back ways fast. Highway 31 and other routes take some of the pressure off. But the honest answer is simple. Live close to where you spend most of your time, and the traffic becomes a non-issue.

Run the Money Side Before You Fall for a Town

Each of these areas pencils out differently. An older Conway house on a big lot, a newer Carolina Forest home with HOA dues and a Market Common townhome can all carry very different monthly costs, even at similar prices. Our lending partner, Elite Home Lending, can run the payment on a specific house so you're comparing real numbers. Getting pre-approved for a home loan before you tour also keeps you from falling for a house that doesn't fit the budget.

I've lived and worked in this market for more than 30 years. When people tell me they're not beach people, I don't try to talk them into an ocean view. I ask how they want to spend a normal Tuesday and build the search around that. If you'd like to know how I approach a search like this, give me a call and we'll talk it through.

Key Takeaways

Conway gives you a river town, bigger lots and quiet streets, roughly 20 to 30 minutes from the ocean. Carolina Forest splits the difference with newer HOA neighborhoods and easy access to Highway 501 and Highway 31. Myrtle Beach proper wins on restaurants, Market Common and the airport, and wherever you land, drive the route in July before you buy.

About Greg Harrelson

Greg Harrelson is a seasoned Realtor® with more than 30 years of experience serving the Myrtle Beach and Grand Strand markets. As the founder of Century 21 The Harrelson Group, Greg has built his career helping buyers, sellers, and investors achieve success in every corner of the coastal Carolina real estate market. His expertise spans residential homes, investment properties, land development, and coastal condos. Known for his deep local knowledge, innovative marketing strategies, and commitment to personal service, Greg consistently helps clients reach their real estate goals while navigating the ever-changing market with confidence and precision.